Mooncity, it is possible for two people to have an entirely different definition of "webcomic." Don't assume that such a definition is self-evident, because it's not. This isn't kittens and biscuits we're talking here, it's kittens and cats.
I propose the following definition (remember, this is a definition SOLELY for use in these awards): If it is listed on TWCL as a webcomic, it is eligible for a TWCL webcomic award. If it is not listed, it is not eligible.
I've made my case as best I can. I'll let the rest of you decide what to do since these are your awards.